Dragon Age II Review


Dragon Age II (released March 8, 2011) is Bioware’s sequel to their late 2009 new RPG IP, Dragon Age: Origins. The new title boasts a dramatically improved graphics engine and combat that is both more fluid and more frenetic than the original’s. However, the new game also has some limitations. Here’s a telling fact, for instance: In DA:O, your epithet by the end of the game is “Hero of Ferelden,” while your moniker in DA2 is “Champion of Kirkwall.” Why does that matter? Well, Ferelden is a country, and Kirkwall is a city. And as that distinction I hope implies, DA2 is a more localized, shorter, and rather meeker affair than its predecessor. Still, it’s a great deal of fun, and if you enjoyed the lore of the first game, you should certainly pick up the latest title. If DA2 had been the first game in the series, it probably would have merited an A in my book. Ultimately, though, the successor falls short of the high standard set by its progenitor, and in the following review, I’ll explain why I think DA2 warrants a B-.

DA2 begins contemporaneously with the events that take place in the latter part of DA:O, but DA2 will span ten years’ time instead of about one year, and it takes place in a different area of the world, the city of Kirkwall. One major change that you’ll notice right away is that, while you can choose your gender and class in DA2 (warrior, rogue, or mage), you cannot choose your race or social standing, as you could in DA:O. This is a perplexing decision on Bioware’s part, as one of the real selling points of the first title was that it included six totally different origin stories, each of which entailed about five hours of game play. These introductions really helped personalize the experience of the game. In DA2, you’re a human, your class doesn’t matter too much in the plot (nor does your gender, really, as most everyone in DA2 is, apparently, bisexual), and despite the decisions that you make throughout the game, your gaming experience is more than likely going to be about the same as everyone else.

The plot of DA2 does not have the immediacy of DA:O, either. In the first title, you had to stop the advance of a terrible arch-demon and his legions. You know that’s your job from the moment that you complete your origin story, and everything you do throughout the game works more or less directly towards the accomplishment of that task. In DA2, well, you know from the beginning that your character is special and is destined to become a “Champion,” but it’s not clear what struggles you will overcome in the service of that title, and for the vast majority of the game, you are left to find things to do, trusting that when the time comes (when you’ve accomplished missions), the game will direct you toward an important primary mission that will advance the story, such as it is. There’s just no immediate threat, and your character’s main task doesn’t seem to be to save the world as much as it is to accrue wealth and buy a big mansion up on the hill.

Still, DA2 boasts some improvements in core game mechanics. As I intimated before, the game simply looks better than DA:O. DA:O’s graphical aesthetics and effects were actually shockingly bad; they looked at least five years behind the times at the moment of the game’s release. DA2 looks respectable for a game today—not as hot as Bioware’s retooled Mass Effect 2 for the PS3, but still perfectly respectable. And these improvements serve to make combat better than ever. Warriors spring into the air and bring their weapons down thunderously on the skulls of enemies. Mages unleash devastating elemental effects and force powers that can throw groups of enemies around like ragdolls. Combat is a quick, messy, and bloody affair. It can be played like a fun third-person shooter/button-masher at lower difficulty levels. But as in the first game, battle can also be paused at any time, and you can, then, issue orders to each of your party members, which they will carry out as soon as you unpause the game. This style is great for the compulsive micromanager, and it is necessary at the higher difficulty levels.

Also you can create complex logic trees for your party members to follow in combat, formatted like If/Then statements (e.g. If my health falls below 25%, drink healing potion). Tweaking these command chains is quite rewarding, because in a certain sense, you can make your party members’ AI as smart as you want it to be, and if a fight proves particularly challenging, you may find that modifying characters’ logic quickly changes the tide of battle. In short, combat is fun, fluid, and gorgeous (in a sticky, wetly sanguineous way).

However, Bioware really dumbed down DA2. You have perplexingly more limited control over party members’ inventories now (you cannot change their armor, just their weapons and trinkets, like rings and amulets). And none of the party members are memorable in the same way as much of DA:O’s cast. Conversations follow the Mass Effect model: There’s a conversation wheel and the main character is fully-voiced. Sounds great? Perhaps. But each conversation option has a little icon by it, marking it as “good,” “evil,” “sarcastic,” etc. This makes for a much less immersive role-playing experience. In the first game, you could feel out which conversations options seemed the most ethical, for instance, but it was up to you to puzzle out this sort of thing. Now, if you want to play a “good guy,” you don’t even need to read the conversation options or listen to the conversations; just keep picking the text that has the “good” icon beside it.

Bioware has also taken some shameful shortcuts as they rushed this title out the door. There are seriously about half a dozen areas where you’ll keep doing combat over, and over, and over. For example, several times you’ll have to do battle in a mansion or estate. It’s always exactly the same map, despite being totally different places from the perspective of the plot of the game. And guess what? The city brothel recycles the same map as well; it just puts a wet bar in the main hall and lodges ladies (and gentlemen) of the night in the sleeping chambers. There are two or three “cave” maps, there’s one “docks” map, and so on. It would be laughably absurd if it weren’t sort of sad and, certainly, repetitive.

The title also has its share of bugs, and, unfortunately, as of the time of this writing, Bioware still hasn’t addressed these with a patch. Bugs run the gamut from headless enemies to peacenik baddies who refuse to fight (i.e. are frozen in place while you wail on them), to bugged bosses that never come down from an inaccessible ledge. Happily, I haven’t heard of any totally game-breaking bugs. Most of the bugs can be solved with a reload of a saved game. See our messageboard thread in which some of us complain about such problems.

So, let me reiterate that while I have a lot of complaining here, I did enjoy the game. It’s wonderfully satisfying to return to the world of Dragon Age, having played the original game, the Awakening expansion, and much of the DLC. The essential problem, in my opinion, is that this game feels way too rushed. This would have been fine if it had been another $40 huge, disc-based expansion like Awakening, but, well, it’s not.

Here’s a bit of perspective: I put over sixty hours into DA:O, about thirty-five into Awakening, and forty into DA2. And I was being pretty OCD with all of these games; many people report DA2 play time of more like twenty-five hours. Nevertheless, DA2 boasts the new engine, which is great and which legitimates dubbing this a brand-new entry in the series. I just wish that more care had been put into building richer content for the flashy new engine to deliver: expanded story, stand-out characters, smarter dialogue, more original areas to explore (and no recycling of areas!), and complex inventory management. The title just feels half-baked. Maybe another six months of development might have done the trick? Unfortunately, I suspect that Bioware’s strategy is to ask me to subsidize rectifying these failings through DLC purchases. Uncool.

Review

ProsCons
Return to the Dragon Age universe
Shiny new graphics engine
Fluid combat designed for consoles (not PC)
Too brief
Less memorable than its predecessors
Too limited in scope
Dumbed down RPG elements
Rating
80%

This review is based on a retail copy of the PS3 version of Dragon Age II provided by BioWare.


Written by: premiersoupir - News Contributor


,

  1. #1 by EdEN on April 14th, 2011 [ 136063 Points ]

    Thanks for the review premiersoupir! I’m thinking about getting the complete edition of DA: O on december 2012 and take it from there since I’ve heard it’s the better of the two games and that I must like the first one to get the most of the sequel since part 2 felt a bit rushed.

    That’s three reviews so far and a great way to get your site trophies hehehe.

  2. #2 by Sinlock on April 14th, 2011

    I would have loved to have done a review of DA2 but between the weeks of house hunting and now closing. I’m just glad I found the time to finish a play through. Might do some of the DLC when they start rolling out.

    Great review!!! Looking forward too more.

  3. #3 by EdEN on April 14th, 2011 [ 136063 Points ]

    By the time I eventually get DA2 I can get it as a complete edition with all the DLC on disc…

  4. #4 by Royalty32 on April 14th, 2011

    DA2 is a good game. Im a newcomer to the series. I never played the first one so i dnt know how the two are different. I didnt finish DA2(plan to though,I traded it in but plan on buyin it again) but i did get really far. Graphics were good and crisp, espacally the magic attacks they look amazing. Voice acting is amazing, you really feel for these characters like they are real people. I do have one major problem though. The whole time i was playing i felt like the game was made for you to be a mage. I played as the rouge class and while it was cool to do vanishing attacks and flips n shit i just didnt feel powerful. While my mage party members would kills enemys in one hit it would take me smashing the x button alot to kill one enemy. Also the story is a little boring in the beginning but once u become champion it really picks up. Great review. My personal score would be an 8.5/10

  5. #5 by Pedro on April 14th, 2011 [ 39949 Points ]

    @premiersoupir Perfect review. I couldn’t have said it better my self.

    The whole thing is exactly how I feel, I completely agree with you on every thing, except this one bit: I really don’t think (as opposed to mostly everyone) the companions aren’t as interesting as the ones from DA:O.

    I really loved their interactions and I felt curious to develop each relation and storyline, feeling I did not share in DA:O. Another thing, I also think they relate much better between each other and even their relations are interesting.

    With that said, great work on the review.

  6. #6 by premiersoupir on April 14th, 2011 [ 17020 Points ]

    @EdEN: If you’re all at curious in the series, do get DA:O. And getting a combined edition sounds like a great idea. As I intimate in the review, DA:O+Awakening can net you a solid 100 hours of awesome role-playing, and that’s not including the DLC (which I don’t recommend, by in large).

    @Royalty32: I played a mage, so… :) I can see how it would be more difficult to play a rogue, unless you specced for an archer. Varric with his crossbow, Bianca, was a monster — I always rolled with him in my party instead of Isabella, despite her obvious… charms…

    @Pedro: Interesting. So whom did you like best in DA2? I thought Merrill was cute. Isabella was annoying eye-candy. Really the only one I had much interest in was Anders, and largely because I knew him from Awakening, so his was perforce the best developed character, I felt.

  7. #7 by GeneticMania on April 14th, 2011 [ 1450 Points ]

    Varric was the best character hands down. I loved his crazy quotes. Fenris was cool. Anders was a cry baby, but I kept him in my party for healing. Rouge was most definitly the strongest class, you just gotta know how to use them.

  8. #8 by Markus on April 15th, 2011 [ 4322 Points ]

    Nice and fair review…

    I got wifey at home, Merill. She’s a hot little Elf with a fat booty. I’m tappin’ Elisabeth on the side, boobage galore… But Anders still won’t get off my d^ck!

    DAMN!

    Yes, yes… We are both mages and we got a lot in common but that doesn’t mean that I want you to touch my naughty parts! Take a hint dude! It’s because you kept pulling that sh^t that I sided with the Templars at the end. It was the only way to get rid of you. GAWD!

    <..>

  9. #9 by chronorayven on April 17th, 2011 [ 21319 Points ]

    I enjoyed this game very much and can’t wait for the new dlc/expansion to come out. Soon I hope. I guess have to play Dragon Age origins now. :P

  10. #10 by Markus on April 17th, 2011 [ 4322 Points ]

    chronorayven: I enjoyed this game very much and can’t wait for the new dlc/expansion to come out. Soon I hope. I guess have to play Dragon Age origins now.   

    You can pick up the DA:O Ultimate Edition for like 45$ if I’m not mistaken. That’s a whole lot of game for your dollar!


You must be logged in to post a comment.

Like trophies? Like giveaways? Want to speak your mind? Register here!