White Knight Chronicles 2 Review


Avatar Creation

The Avatar creation process is full of many unique options. You have full control of your in game Avatar from every feature of the face to the body. There is even a Monster Hunter type voice option where you can chose how he or she will grunt and grown. The story still centers around Leonard, but your Avatar will be with your party from the begging just like the first game. For those of you new to the series, your Avatar is your main character that will be used in Multilayer. The game still allows you to use whichever character you want during single player, but who’s going to pass up on changing into the White Knight?

Graphics and Sound

The game is gorgeous and the amount of detail to the bugs around plants and the ambiance of the sky is simply amazing. The vibrant color pallet brings the world to life. Drop in a killer musical score and a very nice opening song and the world which you spend a good 33hrs in becomes very believable. This is the best part of White Knight Chronicles 2 without a doubt.

MMO Feel

The game from the very start of character creation feels like a free to play MMO. You can pull up a gesture menu at any time and wave and greet and so forth. The items found and looted from chests appear in a news ticker of sorts in the upper left of the screen. The game feels like World of Warcraft and you can see where the team got their inspiration from. Its just such a mix up of stuff that makes nothing work here. The Japanese RPG is there underneath what is obviously an attempt to cater to the Western market. A shame to be honest. You can still make your own town and upload it to the servers for friends to visit and it can serve as a basis for setting out on a long list of mediocre Quests.

Let the Problems Begin

Where do I start with this one. The inclusion of White Knight Chronicles (the first one) International Edition is a great bonus, because if you haven’t played the series before you almost have to start with the first one. You will begin 2 in the level 30+ area and will have no tutorial at all to aid you. This leaves you having to manage hundreds of skills and attacks which must be assigned to your in game attack menu. I spent 2hrs here alone before even setting out on a quest. Major issue for newcomers of the series if you chose to start with 2.

You must assign every single skill and attack which will be chosen via an in game menu during battle. The battle system was supposed to be improved and more fine tuned, but all they did here was speed up an already boring battle system and add a few options like where to hit an enemy while attacking. Your attacks are chosen as stated before and you must wait for a circle to become fully illuminated before hitting X to initiate the attack. Boring doesn’t begin to explain it.

While all this is going on, you have total control over your character, but for what reason? None, to be completely honest. You can try to run around an enemy while charging your attack, but if the enemy is going to hit you, it wont miss if you’re running away, making me wish the battle was turn based even more. They are trying to fake real time battle here and it simply doesn’t work.

The ability to create combos is still here and works much the same way. You add your attacks however you see fit and they use up AC points. These combos are almost pointless, as a decent air combo will use up enough AC points that you’re better off waiting to get a few more to turn into the White Knight and decimate everything in a few whacks.

The option to command your characters to attack how they see fit, or defend, etc, is there to more or less say, “Hey you can do this”. I found it much easier to simply set it to attack what I am attacking and that is how I left it during my play time with no issues.

More Confusion

Imagine starting a movie that you have never seen half way through and you have a general idea of what to expect with White Knight Chronicles 2. There is no character involvement at all. The game assumes you have played the first one and remembers every detail that has occurred during Leonard’s previous escapade. Then you have the politics of this person and that person trying to take over and without no solid story behind it you lose any sort of commitment to the cause. Add in a bunch of fetch and kill quests and you have a very boring title on your hands.

Running around in the forest destroying cores is as fun as it sounds. Find the core and hit it until its gone, all the while backtracking and spending way too much time in one area. While trying to locate your objectives, you will encounter a bunch of smaller enemy types with the a big beast in the center. You simply attack the smaller ones until you earn up enough AC points to transform and smash the big beast in a few unsatisfying whacks. Shoot me now please. Releases in the states on 9-13-2011.

Review

ProsCons
Musical Score
Graphics and detail
Boring combat
No tutorial
Overly Complex menu system
No character involvement
Tries to be too many games
Rating
48%

This review is based on a retail copy of the PS3 version of White Knight Chronicles 2 provided by Level-5.


Written by: Jason - News Contributor


  1. #1 by dragon290513 on July 6th, 2011 [ 7218 Points ]

    but it has the first game enhanced and packed in, have you tried it?

  2. #2 by EdEN on July 6th, 2011 [ 142681 Points ]

    Thanks for the review! I was considering a purchase since it included the first one but will skip this in favor of some games that are actually fun to play and don’t require you to mindlessly grind for hours.

  3. #3 by Ceidz on July 6th, 2011 [ 39166 Points ]

    I was waiting for this game for more than a year. Seeing your review, I’m not sure anymore I even want to play this game.
    Regarless of all the issues you encountered, is the story still solid ?

  4. #4 by Pedro on July 6th, 2011 [ 39949 Points ]

    Such a shame, I think they’ve made a wrong turn somewhere and got lost.

    I had heard so many good things about the 1st one it’s sad to learn the sequel is so terrible.

    In my opinion no game should start at level 30, that makes it sound much more like an expansion pack rather than a game… sad.

  5. #5 by Jason on July 6th, 2011 [ 26201 Points ]

    The story is like I said, uninspiring and builds little to no emotion with character involvement. they simply tryed to please to many people. You understand this is what I feel about the game and this isnt set in stone correct? Numerous other reviews can be found on this game as well. I found a eurogamer review this morning which scored it a 5 out of 10 so the general agreement from those who have played this is the same. It is saddening to have a title your looking forward to bomb, I understand that. My opinion is normal either Buy, Rent or pass with this title falling under pass. They need to tune the combat and focus on one aspect. If your going to act like a MMO, go ahead and be one etc
    @#1Yes I played the original and the new International version bundled on the disc. It doesnt change my opinion on the expierience and the flawed system they have in place.

  6. #6 by Sakinah on July 7th, 2011 [ 26489 Points ]

    The story has never been the strong point for WKC but everyone who have enjoyed it ( including me ) say that the online community is the best part of the game.

    Still getting this in September.

  7. #7 by Ceidz on July 7th, 2011 [ 39166 Points ]

    It’s sad to hear this.
    I enjoyed a lot Rogue Galaxy, their last ps2 game.
    It was wonderful, the combat system was excellent and active (far from the passive one in WKC), and the story was good also !
    I wonder why they changed the battle system so much, it was near-perfect in RG !

  8. #8 by Madagasca on July 7th, 2011 [ 6529 Points ]

    Hey Jason,

    Good review. Shame to see it wasn’t living upto the expectations.

  9. #9 by Madagasca on July 7th, 2011 [ 6529 Points ]

    Hey Jason,

    Good review. Shame to see the game wasn’t living upto the expectations.

  10. #10 by Jason on July 7th, 2011 [ 26201 Points ]

    Madagasca: Hey Jason,Good review. Shame to see the game wasn’t living upto the expectations.  

    It happens. Like I said they just tryed to please to many people.

  11. #11 by Depharius on July 10th, 2011 [ 110 Points ]

    Some points in your review are true but having distance with an enemys increases your chances of missing < found that out by running away from a bounty monster who i underestimated,as a result i was almost shredded in pieces even with 3 knights.
    Using the knights isnt even necessary against big guys.
    The menu explaines itself by the way, what do you find so confusing about it?
    In the manual of the game check "travelogue" it clearly says that the help/tutorial section is in there.

  12. #12 by Jason on July 10th, 2011 [ 26201 Points ]

    Depharius: Some points in your review are true but having distance with an enemys increases your chances of missing < found that out by running away from a bounty monster who i underestimated,as a result i was almost shredded in pieces even with 3 knights.
    Using the knights isnt even necessary against big guys.
    The menu explaines itself by the way, what do you find so confusing about it?
    In the manual of the game check “travelogue” it clearly says that the help/tutorial section is in there.  

    A review copy was provided. Manuals are not included. Having to lay out every single attack in a command menu is overwhelming especially when you can not see the attack differences in detail pertaining to what type of strike it is when assigning. I never said it was necessary. You can sit there and whack away at the hind legs all day but its far easier to change and kill in a few hits. Theres no defending this game. I wouldn’t recommend it to anybody even as a bargain bin. Yes running away from an enemy almost always guarantee’s a direct hit from the enemy as mentioned in the review.

  13. #13 by shadowcrazy on July 11th, 2011 [ 325 Points ]

    48%??? too generous IMO

  14. #14 by Markus on July 12th, 2011 [ 4322 Points ]

    I’m still going to pick this up soon ^^


You must be logged in to post a comment.

Like trophies? Like giveaways? Want to speak your mind? Register here!