[Review Rewind] Magic: The Gathering: Duels of the Planeswalkers 2009


Magic: The Gathering: Duels of the Planeswalkers 2009 should be understood with the benefit of hindsight and experience as a sort of beta test for the latest version of the game, Duels 2012. The 2012 version of the game is essentially identical in its game play mechanics and its visual aesthetics, but 2012 does everything better, featuring a more modern look, more streamlined play, an additional game mode, greater control over deck editing, and – most importantly – better balanced decks. In short, if you’re looking to play Magic on your PS3, buy 2012 and skip this older version.

If you’re new to the Magic card game, you might wish to consult ps3blog.net’s review of Duels 2012, wherein we briefly explain how the game works. Duels 2009 features identical game play, but Duels 2009 is lacking in a few areas. First, the board looks sleeker in the new version, and the new version does a nice job of compacting the user interface (health, cards remaining in deck, etc.) so that more of the board is visible during a game. Also, Duels 2009 plods along a bit more slowly during game play, as the timer during each phase of card play is longer than in the new version. Duels 2012 never feels rushed; on the contrary, Duels 2009 feels too slow. Duels 2009 also lacks the Archenemy game mode that was introduced in Duels 2012. This is not a huge loss, though, for Archenemy seems a bit gimmicky to me, pitting three humans against one powerful AI opponent. The Archenemy mode could potentially be far more interesting if a human were allowed to play the powerful “archenemy.”

However, the above complaints are all rather minor compared to the following two failings of Duels 2009. First, like Duels 2012, Duels 2009 allows the player to unlock cards for a given deck as she proceeds through the campaigns. However, Duels 2009’s extraordinarily limiting deck customization function only allows the player to add or remove the unlockable cards from her deck; all of the deck’s base cards that are unlocked from the get-go must remain in the deck. Deck editing, then, is extraordinarily simplistic and of questionable value. Happily, in 2012, you can add or remove base cards in addition to the unlocked cards. (Though one still cannot mix and match different decks to create an entirely original custom deck.)

The second big draw-back to Duels 2009 is that its decks are poorly balanced. There are eight playable decks in the original game (three DLC expansions add a total of seven more decks), and two of these are overwhelmingly powerful. A number are mediocre and the rest are poor. Of course, in Duels 2012, balance isn’t perfect, and some decks are better than others, but the power differential between the best and worst is much smaller than in the older game. From what I’ve read on the Magic forums, most everyone who played Duels 2009 online played one of the two winning decks, totally forsaking the others. In my opinion, that’s a clear sign of a broken game. However, I cannot personally attest to the decks that people play online, as I have been totally unsuccessful in locating any online games, despite numerous attempts on different days of the week and at different times of day. Everyone has migrated to Duels 2012 (where games are always readily available). You, dear reader, should move to Duels 2012 as well.

Duels 2009 is a fun game. It’s well worth playing, especially when it can be had for free (as it was via PS+ a few weeks ago). However, Duels 2012 is better in every regard. If you want to play Magic on your PS3, the choice between the 2009 and 2012 is obvious: Buy the latter.

Review

ProsCons
Fun strategy card gameWorse in every way than Duels 2012
Rating
40%

(A note about nomenclature: Duels 2009 only appeared on PSN in 2011, but it is popularly referred to as the 2009 edition, as it appeared at that time on Microsoft’s XBLA service.)

This review is based on a retail copy of the PS3 version of Magic: The Gathering: Duels of the Planeswalkers 2009 provided by Stainless Games.

Want to get this game? Then you can:

Buy a $20 PSN Card!

Buy a $50 PSN Card!


Written by: premiersoupir - News Contributor


  1. #1 by Pedro on August 8th, 2011 [ 39949 Points ]

    Good job. Now I definitely know which one to get ;p

    How much for the extra DLC decks? And more importantly, are they worth it? Also, how much is the full game (the 2012 version that is)?

  2. #2 by EdEN on August 8th, 2011 [ 136063 Points ]

    Got this with my PS+ sub and I haven’t tried it yet. Since it was free I can be a bit more forgiving so let’s see how it goes!

    Thanks for the review premiersoupir! Puts the 2012 release into perspective.

  3. #3 by EdEN on August 8th, 2011 [ 136063 Points ]

    @Pedro: 2012 edition is $10.

    Extra DLC Expansions (new challenges) for 2009 edition are $4.99 each and there’s 3 expansions in total. There’s a lot of $0.99 DLC that “unlocks” cards in your deck or makes them foil versions and what not that is NOT needed (and doesn’t bring new trophies) so take that into consideration.

  4. #4 by Pedro on August 8th, 2011 [ 39949 Points ]

    Thanks, so that’s $25,00 for the whole thing right? Well, I think I’ll start with just the game and wait for the DLC price to drop a bit. Thanks Eden!

  5. #5 by premiersoupir on August 8th, 2011 [ 17020 Points ]

    @Pedro: Yes, both Duels 2009 and Duels 2012 are 10 USD. No expansions have been released for Duels 2012 (though the first expansion’s resources are included in the main release, but these assets are currently inaccessible). There are three DLC expansions for Duels 2009, each of which costs 5 USD. If you got Duels 2009 for free, as I did, then by all means play and enjoy it. As I intimate in my review, though, I don’t recommend dumping additional money into a title that is broken and that no one plays anymore. Take the money that you would have put into Duels 2009 (or Duels 2009 DLC) and buy Duels 2010 instead. You might even think of Duels 2012 as “already” having an expansion built-in, for Duels 2012 has ten default decks, whereas vanilla Duels 2009 has eight default decks (and two or three more decks are added with each expansion).

    Also, as @EdEn says, both Duels 2009 & 2012 have a flurry of 1 USD DLC. Don’t be tricked into buying those without knowing what you’re getting into! The “deck unlock” purchases grant you instant access to all the locked cards for a given deck. These are cards that you would get anyway as you continue winning games with a given deck. So your $1 is saving you time winning games. (But in my opinion much of the fun lies in unlocking another card, going back to the deck editor, and comparing stats, seeing what I can cut, etc.)

    The other 1 USD DLC is for “foil conversions” for individual decks. These simply change the look of the cards that you currently have. Cards get new borders and maybe new pictures. This is purely a visual change that has absolutely no bearing on game play. Your cards remain the same. This is a totally useless set of purchases, unless perhaps you want online opponents to be impressed with your skills in spendthrift.


You must be logged in to post a comment.

Like trophies? Like giveaways? Want to speak your mind? Register here!