[PS3 Review] Duels of the Planeswalkers 2013


Magic the Gathering: Duels of the Planeswalkers 2013 (released to PSN on June 19, 2012) is Wizards of the Coast’s latest entry in what is apparently becoming a franchise with yearly sequels. As with Duels 2012, the game’s release teases the release of the latest Core Set of cards in the world of paper Magic. Duels is ultimately a casual introduction to Magic that is designed to increase the audience for the Magic universe at large. Full disclosure: Duels 2012 performed precisely that role for me. I am now an avid player of paper Magic with a large library of physical cards and a few tournaments under my belt.

So how does Duels 2013 stack up to its predecessors, Duels 2012 and Duels 2009? (Click for our reviews of both of the aforementioned games, as well as for the major D12 expansion and deck packs.) In a word, D13 continues Wizard’s tradition of improving on these casual video games, making D13 a great purchase. Those who are curious about the world of collectible card games should absolutely check out the game, and even long-time aficionados of Magic should have fun with it (though they might experience some frustration as well). Are you new to Magic? D13 might just be your “gateway drug” to a new addiction, just as D12 was a year or so ago for me!


Duels 2013 offers ten decks, which showcase a number of different ways of playing Magic. The game does a good job of highlighting the major strengths of the five colors of Magic; there’s a green deck that goes in for big creature aggro, a red deck that boasts a suite of direct damage spells, a blue deck that focuses on tempo control and countermagic (permission), etc. D13 also advertises some of the new creatures and mechanics in paper Magic’s Core Set 2013 with. For instance, a black and white deck that focuses on the Exalted mechanic, a green combo deck (which is something of a revelation, as combo decks are usually more at home in blue and red), and a blue deck that goes all-in on the mill strategy. (In Magic, there are a couple ways of winning. The most typical is to reduce your opponent’s life total to zero. A more esoteric way of winning is to reduce your opponent’s cards to zero; this is called “milling” your opponent.)

The D13 decks are generally quite well-balanced. Of course, some decks are stronger than others, but Wizards has really done a great job of working out balance issues over the course of these Duels games. Each deck is perfectly playable, and the range of strategies that the decks present provides a great opportunity for the Magic neophyte to begin to learn what colors and strategies he or she prefers.

D13 still doesn’t let us build decks from scratch, which is disappointing, but also understandable to a certain degree, as that would disturb Wizard’s careful balancing of the decks against each other. None of these decks would be tournament-worthy in the world of paper Magic, since they’re simply too slow, but they make perfect sense in their own hermetically-sealed environment. The games should play out more slowly here, so those new to Magic don’t feel as if they’ve been defeated before they even knew what was going on.

Nevertheless, deck craft has been improved since D12. Each deck has a core set of sixty cards, of which twenty-four are typically lands (cards that provide the resources needed to put into play creatures and spells), so thirty-six cards are creatures and spells. The point is that while the core game of D12 provided sixteen unlockable cards for each deck, D13 provides an astonishing thirty unlockable cards. You could eventually swap out almost your entire deck with unlockable cards! This means that you can tailor each deck to your own playing style and experiment with very different strategies for each deck. The D13 decks feel much more customizable than those of either of the previous Duels titles.

Duels 13 offers a single-player campaign, a set of “challenges” (fun puzzles that provide a fixed board state that require you to win in one turn – these are surprisingly fun, and they teach “non-linear” thinking in the game), multi-player against one to three opponents, Two-Headed Giant (four player, 2 vs. 2 co-op), and the Planechase game mode. Planechase is a recently-resurrected way of playing Magic, which I abhor. It adds a great deal of variance to the game though die rolls every turn and randomly revealed cards that have weird global, game play-altering effects. Classic multiplayer is great, though. It’s fun to go head-to-head with real opponents and see how others have built their decks. Is your build optimal? How can you tweak your decks to account for the strategies of others?

Since Duels 2012, Wizards has also made some mechanical improvements to the game. (Feel free to skip this paragraph if you are new to Magic or don’t care about some of the finer and less visible details that nevertheless vastly ameliorate the experience.) Still with me? Ok, here it goes: In multi-color decks, you can manually tap lands for mana, which helps to avoid awkward situations in which the AI tapping prevents you from casting another spell. Wizards has (finally!) introduced an end step on each turn, so you can pause on the opponent’s end step and do something (before triggers resolve that care about an end step, for instance). Cards that say “may” now actually act as a “may” instead of a “must” (as in D12) – if you “may” draw an extra card, you don’t necessarily want to be forced to do that if you’re facing a mill strategy, for example. And finally, it is now much easier to pick cards as you can zoom in on a stack of cards (like a creature that has an equipment and an aura attached), so it’s easier to choose whether you want to activate a creature ability or equipment ability.

In short, Duels 13 improves on its predecessors in profound ways. Magic veterans will still be annoyed by the limited deck building, but they may still find the game to be an enjoyable pastime, especially when they don’t have friends to play with in real life. And Magic neophytes may well find a reason to fall in love with the game. Duels is a lot of fun, and it suggests the possibilities that the “real” game of Magic affords. If you’ve any interest in collectible card games, or if you’re the sort of person who tends more toward Tarot and Bridge than Poker, then this might well be the game for you.

Review

ProsCons
Interesting, well-balanced decks
More deck tweaking capability
Major mechanical improvements
No deck-building from scratch
Planechase is a throw-away game mode
Rating
85%

A PS3 copy of Duels of the Planeswalkers 2013 was bought for this review


Written by: premiersoupir - News Contributor


,

  1. #1 by EdEN on August 21st, 2012 [ 140076 Points ]

    Manually taping land! Rejoice, Magic players. The digital game is now closer to the physical edition!

  2. #2 by Isli on August 21st, 2012 [ 44885 Points ]

    The only feature I want is to be able to build your own deck. I’d buy it in a heartbeat if they just added that :(

  3. #3 by EdEN on August 21st, 2012 [ 140076 Points ]

    @Isli: That would be rather expensive with all the booster packs we’d have to buy… but I think it is the direction Wizards will go for the 2014 edition. They can just split the game between pre-built decks and those built from scratch, and they’ll get my money!

  4. #4 by Isli on August 21st, 2012 [ 44885 Points ]

    It might be expensive, but so was the original card game. And it’s much more fun building your own deck than using a generic one.

  5. #5 by premiersoupir on August 21st, 2012 [ 17020 Points ]

    @Isli @EdEN: Much as I hate to play Debby Downer, I think it unlikely that we’ll ever get robust deck-building in Duels. That’s what MTGO is for. Duels is meant to rope people into the MTG experience, such that they start spending money buying boosters and attending tournaments for paper Magic and MTGO.

    That being said, there are excellent alternatives to MTGO if you want your digital fix of Magic and you want to build and test decks. Cockatrice is the best of these options. It’s free, open-source, and multi-platform (Windows, Mac, Linux).

  6. #6 by Isli on August 21st, 2012 [ 44885 Points ]

    Hmm, now if only there was a way to get digital copies of the cards you own.

  7. #7 by EdEN on August 21st, 2012 [ 140076 Points ]

    @Isli: That is a great idea! Include a small QR code on Magic cards, scan with PS3 Eye, and BAM, instant digital card collection! They could even charge you $10 to enable such a feature, and we would still do it hahaha.

  8. #8 by pedrolabate on August 21st, 2012 [ 39949 Points ]

    I have long waited for this review, I missed out on the 2012 edition, but I cannot pass on this one. I’m glad some of the quirks the previous editions had have been solved, this will certainly make for a better experience.

    By the way, congrats on becoming an Author @premiersoupir even though it doesn’t say on your title yet.

  9. #9 by Jay on August 21st, 2012 [ 83111 Points ]

    I think the title won’t change until he makes staff. This is one step below, and was just a change of user group more than title, but I’m hoping he sticks around long enough to make staff. Still, congrats are in order. I haven’t promoted anyone since Clint and Madagasca last year I think lol

  10. #10 by premiersoupir on August 21st, 2012 [ 17020 Points ]

    @EdEN: I think that’s called Eye of Judgment! :) But yeah, it would be really, really awesome if we could do something like that for MTG on the PS3!

    @pedrolabate @Jay: Thanks very much, guys! I’m excited to be an Author. :) And yeah, Pedro, sorry it’s taken me a while to get the review up. I wanted to unlock all of the decks before rendering judgment on the game. And, my word, it takes a long time to unlock all of the cards. There are 300 cards to unlock in all, and you unlock a card whenever you win a game. Then as soon as I unlock a card or two, I go back to the deck editor to tinker with my build. So yeah, it’s a process. Nevertheless, it’s a fun process, at least for me! :)


You must be logged in to post a comment.

Like trophies? Like giveaways? Want to speak your mind? Register here!